Contractual penalties in international contracts
Contractual penalties in international contracts – is it worth introducing them to the contract?
When entrepreneurs initiate collaboration with a foreign business partner, they engage in negotiations concerning various terms and conditions governing the manner in which it will be carried out. They determine among others:
However, there are situations where a foreign business partner fails make the payment, despite having received the goods that were delivered in accordance with the terms of the contract.
In the domestic trade, entrepreneurs are used to the fact that the lack of payment for the delivered goods, which has no justification, will end up in court, and if the case is not overly complicated, the proceedings should run quite smoothly. In this case, however, the goods were delivered abroad. Consequently, a valid questions emerges – which court holds jurisdiction to hear a lawsuit against a contractor-buyer who has failed on payment for the goods he ordered?
In order to answer this question, it is necessary to analyze the content of the contract concluded between the parties, including its subject matter, as well as international legal acts, including EU regulations.
In legal relations within the European Union, the Brussels I bis Regulation, i.e. Regulation No. 1215/2012, will apply. In the case of sales contracts, this regulation indicates that the competent court to hear a dispute between the parties will be the court of the country to which the goods were or were to be delivered. In practice, therefore, it is most often the court of the country competent for the location of the contractor-buyer.
Yes.
The concluding of a jurisdiction agreement in a specific case depends on the negotiation power possessed by a given entrepreneur. In the vast majority of cases, the party with stronger negotiation leverage will secure a favorable jurisdictional solution for themselves. Even if it is not possible to obtain a solution that allows for a dispute to be brought before a preferred court in a particular contract, it is still worth to know what the agreement entails and which court will have jurisdiction. If it is the counterparty’s court, it is possible to apply other types of safeguards against the risk associated with non-payment, such as a higher advance payment for a given order.
It is therefore essential that the entrepreneur knows his legal situation.
Joanna Lubecka
attorney
Contractual penalties in international contracts – is it worth introducing them to the contract?
The common commercial practice is to communicate only in electronic form, through the exchange of e-mails. It should be remembered that in this case a contract is also concluded in the form of a commercial custom adopted by the parties.
Economic cooperation with a foreign contractor can be formalized in several ways. Do you know them? Are any of them better than the others? Let’s see.
In practice, a significant part of the negotiations between the parties is devoted to these provisions.
The international sale of goods is very often associated with the use of Incoterms rules. What are they and why are they so helpful?
Entering into commercial relations with a foreign contractor involves risk. What is the risk in foreign trade and how to increase the security of such transactions? Read more.
Case study
You are engaged in discussions with a potential foreign partner regarding the terms of a possible economic partnership. During the negotiation process, you discover that the partnership is supposed to be governed by a straightforward agreement or purchase order and the standard General Terms and Conditions used by your business partner.
Confidentiality clause is a contractual provision on the basis of which the parties decide to accept that the information specified by them, indicated in the contract, will be confidential, and therefore cannot be freely available to third parties, under the pain of the consequences specified in the contract.
Case study